Okay, it's time to take on this evolution thing. I think I have understood for the first time what Darwin may have observed and why the Galapagos were so important in the history of the study of evolution. We were traveling with a naturalist and he explained it this way.
The Galapagos are situated at an important position in the Pacific. Normally the cold Humboldt Current flows north, then turns west at the equator. The warm Panama Current normally flows south and also turns west at the equator. These two mix to form the west-flowing Equatorial Current. To keep things in balance there is a deep-water east-flowing Equatorial Undercurrent. This is important because the two equatorial currents meet exactly at the position of the Galapagos and create an incredible food-rich environment for marine life. With me so far?
On an annual cycle, there is a cool dry season, and a warm wet season. During the cool dry season, the waters are cold and food-rich ... marine life explodes in the abundance. But there is little rain and life on land is dormant.
During the warm wet season, the rains come. Food becomes abundant on land, and life there explodes while marine life struggles in the food poor warmer waters. That's the normal cycle. A cycle of dormancy, but not species threatening.
Every 5-7 years, the cold Humboldt Current deteriorates and the surface current flowing past the Galapagos becomes slower, but much warmer and profoundly food poor. About 60% of the marine life dies. Above normal rainfall allows life on land to recover. This is called El Nino.
Every 5-7 years, but off cycle with El Nino, the warm Panama Current deteriorates and the water flowing past the Galapagos becomes much colder and is super food rich but the rains fail and food above the ground becomes profoundly scarce. Marine life recovers but about 60% of the bird and animal life dies. This is called La Nina.
When 60% of the life dies, only the strongest members of each species survive. Tiny genetic differences in favored members convey unique survival advantage and get passed on to offspring. The species changes over time. The mechanism of evolution.
What did Darwin observe and why did it have to be here?
Normally evolution takes a long time. But with the rapid El Nino/La Nina cycle, evolution happened here at a hyper-fast rate. It happened so fast in fact that a single human being could observe evolutionary changes occurring during their life time. Enter Charles Darwin; right place, right time. Darwin observed that Finches were changing. Being a smart guy, and because it was his job, he wrote his observations down in The Origin of Species and the rest is history.
I'm not going to enter the Intelligent Design vs Evolution debate here. But if you've been to the Galapagos and understood what's going on, you cannot doubt that evolution is a real and observable force on the planet. Intelligent life elsewhere in the universe? Time will tell. We'll we believe what we see, or see what we believe?